Tertuis Simmers, the Western Cape MEC for Infrastructure, finds himself at the center of controversy after it was revealed that he owns three properties while residing in a state-rented estate, raising questions about ethics and financial prudence within the DA.

Opposition parties have raised concerns about the DA's ethical stance following revelations from party insiders regarding Simmers' living arrangements. Despite owning two properties just kilometers from his workplace, he currently resides in a state-rented estate.

In response to the unfolding situation, Simmers issued a statement last Friday defending his position. He clarified that his primary residence remains in the Garden Route, a considerable 450 kilometers from his seat of office. Simmers stated, "My family remains at that residence while I fulfill my functions as a member of the executive council for the Western Cape."

Additionally, Simmers confirmed that he had acquired two properties for investment purposes, specifically as rental flats. Importantly, the purchase of these properties was in line with public disclosure requirements, as he declared them to the provincial legislature and the provincial Cabinet, as stipulated in the Ministerial Handbook.

The revelation that Simmers resides in Century City, with the government covering his rent, while owning properties in Parklands, which is just 11 kilometers from his state residence, has sparked questions about his eligibility for housing benefits. The Ministerial Handbook dictates that once a member of the executive council buys a house within a 50-kilometer radius of the Western Cape Legislature and has it registered in their name, it disqualifies them from a housing allowance benefit. However, this rule applies solely to a primary residence, which does not encompass Simmers' properties.

In response to concerns, Simmers stated, "The property I own within the 50-kilometer radius of the Western Cape Legislature is not my primary residence, and others I may invest in will similarly not be primary residences. I am eligible for the benefit, by the book. I comply. I am accountable. I am transparent."

Simmers highlighted his obligation to honor his rental agreement in Century City, emphasizing his commitment to ethical conduct. While some lease contracts include vacation notice periods, Simmers asserted that he would not jeopardize his integrity for personal gain.

Notably, Simmers' situation has emerged just two weeks before the DA holds its crucial provincial congress, during which he will contest for the provincial leader position against former leader Bonginkosi Madikizela.

The ANC's provincial spokesperson, Muhammad Khalid Sayed, questioned Simmers' ethical conduct, stating that it raises concerns for a party that often criticizes the misuse of taxpayers' money, particularly from an MEC responsible for providing housing to the public.

The EFF echoed these sentiments, emphasizing the DA's ethical leadership shortcomings. Carlos Mesquita, spokesperson for the Good party's MPL Peter de Villiers, also expressed concern over Simmers' situation, which, while not unlawful, is seen as highly unethical.

The office of Premier Alan Winde, represented by Regan Thaw, had no further comments to add to Minister Simmers' response. The situation has ignited a broader debate about ethics, public representation, and the responsible use of taxpayer funds within the province.

‍